Today in History: Hitler fails attempted coup (Beer Hall Putsch)

Hitler is focused on quite often in any sort of historical recounting of the early 20th century and we all know why that is. However, the global "history books" tend to look more at the aspects of the man once he already was in power rather than the various steps that took place on his way to that position. The Beer Hall Putsch is one of these events and while I know this is a "Captain Hindsight" moment - had these events turned out just a little bit different, the global 30's and 40's could have been significantly changed.

The year was 1923

I bet you can't guess which one is Adolf!

Before we go any further, you should know that "putsch" is simply a German word that means "coup d'etat" or basically an attempt to overthrow a government by force.

Beer halls were massive pubs basically, and while I have only ever attended a replica in an amusement park in USA they were quite impressive structures. Just imagine a place where hundreds or even thousands of people gathered to drink beer and socialize. These forums were also where national or even global issues were discussed - most of the time with civility.

Hitler's presentation that night was anything but civil and mostly it was filled with lies. However, as I am sure you are aware Hitler has been well documented as being a tremendous speaker and people were drawn to his charisma.

He originally took the podium in this beer hall (called "Bürgerbräukeller" - which was demolished in the 70's) by firing a gun and demanding silence. Germans then (and now, some would argue) are not easily frightened but the fact that Hitler had brought a rather large group of armed soldiers with him as well as a highly-respected General, Erich Ludendorff, convinced the large crowd to bend their collective ear.

They had specifically chosen this location because it was known that many of the current political leaders of Munich would be in attendance. The idea was that they would kidnap these leaders and force them to swear loyalty to Hitler, and thereby take over the government of Bavaria, gain momentum, and eventually seize power of the entire country.

Once the floor was yielded to Adolf, he proclaimed:

"The Bavarian and Reich governments have been removed and a provisional national government formed. The barracks of the Reichswehr and police are occupied. The Army and the police are marching on the city under the swastika banner!"

None of this was true of course, but such is the power of propaganda. Hitler's message, however, did resonate with a great many in attendance, and they joined the march in the streets towards the government buildings along with the attendees of several other beer halls (there were many other things that happened in-between but I'm trying to condense this.)

it's like a really easy "Where's Waldo"

Things got messy when Hitler's group encountered over 100 soldiers and police who were organized to stop the march. On their way to the Defense Ministry shots were fired by both sides and 4 police officers and 16 Nazis were killed.

This is where the first thing happened that could have changed the outcome of the next 20 years: Hitler's bodyguard jumped on top of him and absorbed multiple gunshots - likely saving his life.

The group of nearly 3000 marchers were dispersed or arrested, but Hitler had been rushed away in a car to a friend's house. This is where the 2nd thing that could have changed history happened: Hitler, facing a defeat that he he spent a great deal of time planning, was going to commit suicide. The Hanfstaengl family (his friends) spent days talking him out of doing so.

In 3 days Hitler was arrested and was set to face trial for high treason and this is where another big mistake was made that almost certainly molded the mindset of Germany into one that was eventually willing to hand over power over to Hitler.


The powers that be at the time had hoped to make Hitler look like a villain during the trial and therefore massive press was allowed at the 24-day proceedings. True to what we know about the man today, he was so charismatic and selective with the words he used in his defense, that the population, a majority of people in attendance and even 2 of the 3 judges agreed with Hitler. The main judge reportedly had to spend quite a deal of time convincing the other 2 to find him guilty at all and was only able to do so if an extremely light sentence with a very early chance of parole was the eventuality.


He also received a very nice cell, was allowed to receive gifts, and was also able to have visitors anytime he wanted. He utilized this time to author Mein Kampf as well as plan his actions upon his release. Being found guilty of treason normally could have a much harsher sentence than 5 years associated with it (up to life) and it certainly isn't something that a person would be released from their relatively luxurious (and free) accommodation in a period of just nine months. However, this is precisely what happened.

A previously relatively unknown man was now known around the world. During his trial he captured a nation-wide audience that had never even heard of him. His patriotic message resonated with a great deal of the population and as strange as it sounds, Hitler's conviction of treason is likely the main reason behind how the national Nazi party gained widespread appeal and of course lead to the terrible outcome that we are all so familiar with today.

It all began today, nearly 100 years ago.

Comments 14

To listen to the audio version of this article click on the play image.

Brought to you by @tts. If you find it useful please consider upvoting this reply.

08.11.2019 06:21

Hitler's passion for opposing the government was a heroic side built by Hitler. he was able to give a fiery speech so that he could take the side of the German population in awe. With good propaganda he can persuade great power to overthrow power. Unfortunately he failed the coup on November 8, 1923.
Despite failing to stage a Hitler coup, he could lay the foundations of his ultranasiomalism. By languishing in prison he was able to produce a monumental work, Mein Kampf, who later aroused the spirit of Germany in conquering the world because it felt as the highest race, the Aryan race.
but behind it all Hitler also made the destruction of Germany. Germany is getting worse in the world political arena. After losing the first world war that he participated in and getting various titles, then in the second world war German also had to defeat.

08.11.2019 06:41

Wow! That is insane. He must have been one hell of a speaker to get the court on his side after pulling that stunt.

Basically, his coup just got him free exposure. I guess it really is true that all publicity is good publicity.

08.11.2019 09:50

lol, no kidding. If they had just quietly had a trial a whole lot of death could have been prevented.

08.11.2019 10:46

Interestingly enough, that same beer hall almost became the end of Hitler sixteen years later. On November 8th 1939 Hitler, then already in power, attended the memorial ceremony there. He had to cut his attendance short and left an hour earlier than usual. That saved his life, because a bomb exploded, killing 8 people and injuring 63. The investigation later revealed that the bomb was built and set by Georg Elser, a carpenter with Communist sympathies. Elser was apprehended and put in Dachau Concentration Camp where he was executed in April 1945, shortly before Hitler's downfall.

08.11.2019 10:58

ah, what a fantastic follow-up. I think I remember reading something about it but didn't know the details. Thanks for that.

08.11.2019 11:31

Wow, that is really interesting. I don't know as though I knew all of those facts. I really need to start reading more I guess. Now that I have been out of school for so long I have just shifted my learning to other areas even though there are still things that interest me like this. Thanks for sharing. Great post!

08.11.2019 11:51

well i think you and I are around the same age and we weren't taught these things in school. We given a very short history of Hitler BAD, D-Day ,USA save day, Next chapter!

08.11.2019 12:01

In high school for sure. College was a little different, I had an awesome class that dug deep into things like the French Revolution and World War 1. It was probably one of my favorite classes.

08.11.2019 12:03

I would have enjoyed that also. My college curriculum featured exactly zero history though 😝

08.11.2019 13:35

Amazing what someone with the power of speech can do. I really enjoy going back in time with your posts as they are all interesting.

08.11.2019 15:48

thanks pal. This one was a lot of fun to research since I am already a WW2 nerd anyway. I think the history articles are my favorites to write because even if the subject matter is something that I already know a great deal about, there is always a little detail hidden in there that a person probably didn't already know and I enjoy knowing new stuff :)

10.11.2019 16:08


08.11.2019 16:11

09.11.2019 16:04